The 5 Best Eyeliners

The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner 202 Black Brown is our first pick for this guide. 4.5 stars across 54,500 Amazon ratings at research time. It is best suited to shoppers comparing eyeliner makeup women options.

The wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich is the lowest-priced option in this shortlist at approximately $1. Choose it when price matters, while checking its stated limitations before buying.

The 8Pcs Retractable Creamy Eyeliner & Eyeshadow Sticks is the highest-priced option in this comparison at approximately $9.99. It is worth considering when its features and intended use justify the additional cost.

The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner 202 Black Brown is our stronger overall fit for recommendations must directly serve the “eyeliner” use case.. The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner Waterproof Liquid is the better alternative for shoppers comparing eyeliner makeup women options. It may not suit you if the exact size, compatibility, ingredients or specification does not match your needs.

Start with recommendations must directly serve the “eyeliner” use case.. We then compare Amazon.com listing and ASIN relevance, specifications that affect the stated use case, review depth and rating evidence where available, price, availability and meaningful limitations, along with the limitations that could make a product unsuitable for your needs.

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner Waterproof Liquid is our shortlist choice for shoppers comparing eyeliner makeup women options. 4.5 stars across 107,500 Amazon ratings at research time. Skip it if the exact size, compatibility, ingredients or specification does not match your needs.

Consider another option if the exact size, compatibility, ingredients or specification does not match your needs. The other four recommendations cover different budgets, priorities and use cases.

The products in this guide currently span approximately $1 to $9.99. The right budget depends on the features you need, so compare the best-for and skip-if notes before paying more.

We evaluated five current options against the exact search intent, recommendations must directly serve the “eyeliner” use case., relevant specifications, buyer evidence, availability, price and meaningful trade-offs. Affiliate commission does not determine inclusion or position.

This guide was last reviewed on 2026-09-02. Prices, sellers, variants and availability can change, so confirm the final details with the retailer before purchasing.