5 Best Eyeliners
Five eyeliners, including NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP and REVLON, compared by tip format, wear time and removal.
Our top 5 eyeliners
Swipe to compare price, rating and best use →
| Product | Price | Rating | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
01 NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HRDetails ↓ | $9.99 | 4.5/5Amazon | Best overall |
02 Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof EyelinerDetails ↓ | $7.59 | 4.5/5Amazon | Best for easy setup |
03 FangTangDI 8Pcs Retractable Creamy Eyeliner & EyeshadowDetails ↓ | $9.99 | 4.0/5Amazon | Best for more features |
04 wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof RetractableDetails ↓ | $2.28 | 4.5/5Amazon | Best for compact spaces |
05 docolor Liquid EyelinerDetails ↓ | $6.34 | 4.2/5Amazon | Best value |
01 — NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Best overallNYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HR
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HR Wear has a matte finish, waterproof construction, 24-hour wear claims. Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control. Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye.
View on Amazon ↗Reasons to buy
+NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HR Wear has a matte finish, waterproof construction, 24-hour wear claims.
Reasons to avoid
−Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Tip format, wear time and removal can vary by configuration.
- ProductType
- eyeliner makeup women
02 — REVLON
Best for easy setupRevlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner has a matte finish, waterproof construction, a named shade. Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control. Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye.
View on Amazon ↗Reasons to buy
+Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner has a matte finish, waterproof construction, a named shade.
Reasons to avoid
−Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Tip format, wear time and removal can vary by configuration.
- ProductType
- eyeliner makeup women
03 — FangTangDI
Best for more featuresFangTangDI 8Pcs Retractable Creamy Eyeliner & Eyeshadow
FangTangDI 8Pcs Retractable Creamy Eyeliner & Eyeshadow Sticks for Women has a matte finish, a satin finish, waterproof construction. This configuration includes black White Brown Blue Purple Green Gray Colors, Ultra Pigmented Waterproof Mechanical Eye Pencils. Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control. Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye.
View on Amazon ↗Reasons to buy
+FangTangDI 8Pcs Retractable Creamy Eyeliner & Eyeshadow Sticks for Women has a matte finish, a satin finish, waterproof construction.
Reasons to avoid
−Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Tip format, wear time and removal can vary by configuration.
- ProductType
- eyeliner makeup women
04 — wet n wild
Best for compact spaceswet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof Retractable
wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof Retractable Gel Eyeliner - has a satin finish, waterproof construction, a vegan formula. This configuration includes smudge Proof Satin Finish Formula, Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Dark Brown. Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control. Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye.
View on Amazon ↗Reasons to buy
+wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Waterproof Retractable Gel Eyeliner - has a satin finish, waterproof construction, a vegan formula.
Reasons to avoid
−Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Tip format, wear time and removal can vary by configuration.
05 — docolor
Best valuedocolor Liquid Eyeliner
docolor Liquid Eyeliner has waterproof construction, water-resistant construction, a vegan formula. This configuration includes black Eyeliner Pen, Waterproof Eye liner - 1 Pack. Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control. Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye.
View on Amazon ↗Reasons to buy
+docolor Liquid Eyeliner has waterproof construction, water-resistant construction, a vegan formula.
Reasons to avoid
−Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Tip format, wear time and removal can vary by configuration.
Price information
Amazon price and availability checked Oct 18, 2026, 12:07 PM Lisbon time. Prices and availability are subject to change; the information shown on Amazon.com at purchase applies.
Our process
How we picked.
We compare five relevant products for different needs, using documented specifications, clear use cases and practical trade-offs. Our goal is to make the differences clear and help you choose with confidence.
- 01Relevance
Each product must fit the guide’s intended use, audience and requirements.
- 02Specifications
We compare the key product details that meaningfully affect the buying decision.
- 03Use case and fit
We compare the intended use, configuration and practical fit of every selected product.
- 04Strengths and limitations
We explain where each option performs best and the compromises to consider.
Good questions
FAQ — Eyeliners
01What matters most when choosing eyeliners?+
Compare tip format, wear time and removal. Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control.
02Which type of eyeliners fits everyday use?+
Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control.
03How can I check the fit or compatibility of eyeliners?+
Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Tip format, wear time and removal should match your intended use.
04When should I pay more for eyeliners?+
Pay more when a specific feature improves your own use. Pencil, gel and liquid tips create different lines and need different levels of control.
05How should I care for eyeliners?+
Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Follow the maker's cleaning and storage directions for the exact model.
06What mistake should I avoid before buying eyeliners?+
Waterproof formulas often need a dedicated remover near the eye. Compare the complete configuration and included parts, not the family name alone.
The short answer
Start with the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Eyeliner with Up To 24HR.
It is our first pick for this guide’s exact scope. Choose another option when its stated use case or trade-off better matches yours.
View on Amazon ↗Keep looking
Related guides
The 5 Best Electric Shavers
Five electric shavers, including Philips Norelco 2400 Series and Philips Norelco 3600 Electric, compared by foil or rotary head, wet use, cleaning and replacement blades.
The 5 Best Eyeshadow Palettes
Five eyeshadow palettes, chosen for useful everyday performance, practical features and clear value for the intended use.
The 5 Best Concealers
Five concealers compared by coverage, finish, shade range and area of use.